Menu
Testing The Waters
Exploded Fries
$9
Cheesy bacon french fries topped with Alfredo and green onion!
Anchors Away Artichoke Dip
$11
Warm marinated artichoke heart spread with garlicky bread for dippin’!
Gosh Darn Good Garlic Bread
$6.5
Butter, garlic, and parmesan cheese!
Float On The Lake Fried Cauliflower
$7.5
Naked, Buffalo, Garlic and Olive Oil, Gi’s Spice, Koji (serrano pepper and garlic). Choose your dunk!
Chunky Dunk Chicken Wings
$13
5 per serving! Served with our handmade Ranch for dippin’!
Choose your dunk: Naked, Buffalo, Garlic and Olive Oil, Gi’s Spice, Koji (serrano pepper and garlic).
Calamari Fries
$12
Planks of fried calamari served with tartar and cocktail sauce for dippin’!
Southwest Fried Eggrolls
$10
Smoked white meat chicken, black beans, corn, and more! Served with Ranch!
From the Fryer:
French Fries $5
Fried Pickles $7
Onion Rings $6
Onion Paddles $6
Waffle Fries $6
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries $6
Fried Jalapenos $6
Sail Away Soups And Salads
House-Made Dressings: Italian, Ranch, Blue Cheese, Thousand Island (extra sides $2)
Soup of the Day
Cup $5
Bowl $8
Ricky Ray’s Red Hot Chili
$12
A bowl of our meaty beany chili with a side of sour cream corn bread!
Blue Cheese Canoe
$12
A “canoe” of cool iceberg topped with crumbled blue cheese, bacon, red onion, sweet tomato, and our blue cheese dressing on the side!
House by the Lake Salad
Half 6
Full 12
Keep it simple with our house iceberg salad mix, a few fresh veggies, shredded mozzarella cheese, and your choice of one of our house-made dressings.
Add a Chicken Breast or Hamburger Patty to any salad $5
Paddle Away Pizzas
Pizza
1 Topping = $24 Large/$14 Small
2 Toppings = $26 Large/$16 Small
3 Toppings = $28 Large/$18 Small
Our handmade and shaped dough topped with a specially selected blend of cheeses with your choice of our porcini mushroom “gravy” (sauce), red marinara sauce, or white sauce make our pizzas simply unique! Build your own from the items below or choose one of our specialty pizzas!
Add $1.50 sm/$3 lg for each additional topping. Sorry, no substitutions on specialty pizzas.
Toppings: Pepperoni, Salami, Italian Sausage, Bacon, Black Olives, Green Olives, Red Onion, Pepperoncini, Sweet Bell Pepper, Artichoke Hearts, Mushrooms, Pineapple, Ham, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Tomato, Anchovies
The BLT Combo
Large $29 / Small $19
Pepperoni, salami, Italian sausage, sweet bell pepper, red onion, black and green olives, mushroom, porcini mushroom “gravy!”
Mom’s Spicy Pizza
Large $26.5 / Small $16.5
Pepperoni, mushroom, Italian sausage, pepperoncini, sprinkled with Gi’s spice, porcini mushroom “gravy!”
The Make It a Great Day Margherita
Large $27 / Small $17
Fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato, parmesan cheese, olive oil!
The Skinny Dip
Large $24 / Small $14
A combo of our veggies, whole-milk mozzarella, porcini mushroom “gravy!”
Meat Lovers
Large 28
Small 18
Pepperoni, salami, Italian sausage, bacon, porcini mushroom gravy!
Practically Perfect Pinsas
Hailing from Rome, our pinsa doughs are crispy ovals with crevices of delightful goodness! Easily digestible, made from wheat, rice and soy flours!
Pepperoni Pinsa
$16.5
So good and simple!
Artichoke Pinsa
$16.5
Whole-milk mozzarella, artichoke hearts, mushrooms!
Build Your Own Pinsa
$16.5
Choose TWO toppings from our list above!
Boat Load Of Burgers and dogs
All burgers are served with a side of crinkle fries or side house salad! We use freshly ground, local Bently Ranch beef! GAP step 4, hormone free, antibiotic free, grass fed and finished, GMO free! All burgers are 8 oz, seasoned, and cooked medium, unless otherwise requested.
Keepin’ It Simple Burger
$11.5
Easy, peasy, squeezy…a burger patty, American cheese, Tavern sauce. That’s it…that’s awesome!
Portobello Mushroom Burger
$13.5
Skip the rock, I mean, the beef! We fill a portobello mushroom cap with pesto, sundried tomato, and melted whole-milk mozzarella!
The Tavern Burger
$14.5
Our signature burger is topped with crumbled blue cheese, crisp bacon, fresh tomato slices, lettuce, and our Tavern sauce! Let’s hear it for BLTavern!!!
Pizza Burger
$14
Your hamburger patty is heading for the high dive! We add pepperoni, salami, our famous porcini mushroom “gravy,” and melted whole-milk mozzarella!
American BBQ Burger
$12.5
Your burger patty is topped with fried onion rings, American cheese, and BBQ sauce!
Hometown Hot Dog
$13.5
Your choice of beef or polish dog, fresh tomato, onion, and dill pickle! (add chili 3.5)
Sink Or Swim Sandwiches
All sandwiches served with fries or side house salad! (Upgrade “From the Fryer” $2)
Wheat, Sourdough, Hamburger Bun or *Pinsa( *add $3) bread!
Artichoke Chicken Sandwich
$15.5
A juicy, boneless chicken breast is topped with warm, creamy artichoke dip, melted mozzarella, and fresh tomato slices!
Fried Chicken Sandwich
$14.5
A juicy, boneless chicken breast is breaded and takes a swim in the fryer, rides tandem with a bit of Alfredo sauce, and floats to the top with dill pickle slabs!
New York Steak Sandwich
$14.5
A sizzling New York steak, caramelized onions, mushrooms and melted pepper jack cheese, fresh tomato and crunchy lettuce on a French roll!
Spicy Chicken Wrap
$12.5
A spinach tortilla wraps its goodness around spicy chicken breast, sweet bell pepper, onion, and cheese! A schmear of our Baja sauce finishes it off
The Yacht Club
$14.5
A boneless chicken breast, crispy bacon, fresh lettuce and tomato will float your boat!
Meatball Sub
14
Our handmade meatballs are smothered with our porcini mushroom “gravy” and whole-milk mozzarella cheese!
GOOOOOOOOOD STUFF
Tavern Tacos (2 per order)
$10
Flour tortillas are fried and stuffed with seasoned ground beef, chicken, or veggies, sharp cheddar cheese, lettuce, and our house-made salsa! Served with tortilla chips on the side!
Fish Tacos (2 per order)
$12
Soft flour tortillas are filled with our beer battered flakey cod, cabbage, and Baja sauce! Served with tortilla chips on the side!
Fish and Chips
$13
Our beer battered flaky cod is fried to perfection and served with handmade tartar sauce, fresh lemons, and fries on the side! Winning!!!
Chicken Strips
$11
A good ol’ classic…breaded chicken strips and fries! Served with ranch dressing for dippin’!
Dive Off The Dock Desserts
beignets - Warm, sugary pillows of goodness served with caramel or chocolate for dippin’!
$6
Vanilla Bean ice cream with Chocolate Sauce
$5.5
Dark Chocolate ice cream
$5
Pollywog Kids Menu
(Suggested for 10 and under)
Chicken Strips and Fries
$6
Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza
$6
Cheese Quesadilla and Fries
6
Mini Cheese Burger and Fries
$6
Mini Corn Dogs and Fries
$6
Shallow End Drinks
Coke
Diet Coke
Sprite
Root Beer
Dr. Pepper
Lemonade
Apple Juice
Cranberry Juice
Iced Tea
Please notify us if you have any food intolerances or allergies
We can split your entrée for an additional $5 OR (at no charge) bring you an extra plate and you can divvy things up yourself
Unfortunately, there are times when we have to exercise our right to refuse service to a guest
Warning, consuming raw or undercooked meat may increase your risk of foodborne illness
Please notify us if you have any food intolerances or allergies
We can split your entrée for an additional $5 OR (at no charge) bring you an extra plate and you can divvy things up yourself
Unfortunately, there are times when we have to exercise our right to refuse service to a guest
Warning, consuming raw or undercooked meat may increase your risk of foodborne illness